I just read this blog post at PDNedu which referred to an article by Mindy McAdams called What I learned from the online photojournalists. For some reason it really struck a nerve - not in a bad way, just in as much as it really made me want to reply... which is what I did:
"As much as I'm in favor of Visual Journalism, I just don't see the video camera taking over for the still camera. While I'm certainly no expert on the subject, and this is all just my opinion... having done the kind of video that newspapers are starting to do, I can honestly say that I feel there's a big part of 'shooting' that a video camera doesn't fill as well as a still camera. My quick reasons:
- Shutter speed. You're always shooting at a 1/30 or 1/60 shutter speed, if you do otherwise the video looks funny. Sooooo.. do you really think a 'camera' that only shoots at two speeds can take over the industry? I don't. Yes, that $1500 HDR-HC3 shoots at 1/240.. great, you have 3 shutter speeds.
- Ergonomics. Can anyone you know hold a video camera as comfortably and stably as a still camera? I can't. I use a tripod for almost everything. Do you want to shoot all your assignments with a tripod?
- Speed of workflow. The new P2 cards aside, working with MiniDV tapes is a pain in the butt. Even with disc based recording there's a big gap between the speed of editing a folder full of stills and video clip where you're looking for the best still grab.
- Lens choice. Unless you're looking at buying something like the Canon XL series, you don't have the option of switching lenses on most of these cameras. While the optical zoom range is pretty large, can you really say that the quality of the lenses is up to par with L glass or the Nikkor glass? Ziess makes good glass, but do you really think you're getting their best stuff in a pro-sumer $1500 camera? Probably not.
Again, sorry that I seem to have gone off. It started to just flow once I got going.
I love the video movement, and it's cool to seem something new ruffle everyone's feathers. I would imagine it separates those that really want to work for their jobs and those that are just in it to work. I just feel that there's a lot of hype that's freaking people out when it really shouldn't."